Latest Shelter Island and East End Real Estate Transfers Reviewed

The Shelter Island Reporter recently released its weekly property transaction roundup, showcasing residential sales data compiled by Suffolk Vision Inc. These filings highlight market movements across Shelter Island Heights and several neighboring regional communities.

Property values continue to fluctuate across the East End, with transactions ranging from mid-tier suburban homes to multi-million dollar waterfront estates. Reviewing these regional transfers gives buyers and sellers essential insight into current local market valuations.

Shelter Island Heights and Aquebogue Activity

In the heart of Shelter Island Heights (11965), residential sales saw steady local interest. Christine Robinson and Rosemary Foltis successfully transferred 26 Ole Buck Run to Tyler Shepherd and Rachael Brown-Bofinger for $995,000.

Aquebogue Home Sales

Moving westward into Aquebogue (11931), market activity remained active with notable single-family acquisitions. Jonathan and Jennifer Russo officially parted with their property located at 63 Crystal Drive, selling the home to Matthew Spinelli for $721,000. For those fascinated by property layouts, studying home design trends helps explain why these particular neighborhoods remain consistently desirable.

Cutchogue and Mattituck Transactions

The neighboring community of Cutchogue (11935) recorded a significantly higher price point during the same weekly tracking period. Alicia Martinez-Fonts and Maria Madruga transferred ownership of 2150 Haywaters Road to Susan Vlahakis for an impressive $1,470,000.

Mattituck Market Shifts

Mattituck (11952) experienced a pair of distinct residential transactions reflecting diverse buyer budgets. Long Island Investor Group LLC sold 780 Westview Drive for $795,000, while Maria Karastathis closed out a separate deal at 15 Youngs Avenue for $650,000.

Orient and Southold Waterfront Deals

Further down the fork in Orient (11957), trust-owned properties changed hands within the local market. The Jim Welles Trust finalized the transfer of 275 Munn Lane over to 275 Munn Lane LLC for a total consideration of $1,260,000.

Southold Luxury Sales

Southold (11971) undeniably dominated this week’s report by capturing the highest overall transaction figures. Head Of The Harbor LLC sold 19620 Soundview Avenue for a staggering $4,000,000, while a neighboring parcel at 20210 Soundview Avenue traded between LLC entities for $2,075,000.

• Total weekly volume spanned multiple Suffolk County zip codes.
• Waterfront properties in Southold commanded the highest price tags.
• Trust and LLC transfers remained prominent across the East End.

Examining these regional trends provides valuable perspective for anyone tracking coastal real estate shifts. Whether looking at historic properties or new coastal builds, understanding these patterns is crucial for navigating the market.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Shelter Island Reporter Real Estate Transfers: Oct. 24, 2026